Brown Sugar Bakery Menu (Update 2025)
Brown Sugar Bakery, located in Chicago, is a must-visit for dessert lovers. This bakery offers a wide variety of cakes, pies, and cupcakes that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. Customers rave about the caramel cake, lemon ice box pie, and red velvet cupcake. The owner, Stephanie Hart, has created a welcoming atmosphere that exudes a sense of community. The bakery is known for its high-quality ingredients and delicious treats, making it a popular spot for special occasions and everyday indulgences. Don't miss out on trying the popular caramel cake or the unique rainbow sherbet cupcake. With friendly staff and a cozy ambiance, Brown Sugar Bakery is a hidden gem that will leave you craving more.
Same-Day Menu
Carmel Cheesecake Slice
Cheesecake Slice - Plain
Strawberry Cheesecake Slice
Turtle Cheesecake
Caramel Cake Slice
Carrot Cake Slice
Double Dark Chocolate Cake Slice
German Dark Chocolate Cake Slice
Lemon Cake Slice
Pineapple Coconut Cake Slice
Turtle Cake Slice
Vanilla Cream & Caramel Cake Slice
Yellow Chocolate Cake Slice
Caramel Jumbo Cupcake
Dark Chocolate Jumbo Cupcake
German Chocolate Jumbo Cupcake
Lemon Jumbo Cupcake
Rainbow Sherbet Jumbo Cupcake
Red Velvet Jumbo Cupcake
Strawberry Jumbo Cupcake
Turtle Cupcake
Yellow Chocolate Jumbo Cupcake
Carmel
German Dark Chocolate
Double Chocolate Dark
Obama
Pineapple Coconut
Rainbow Sherbet
Red Velvet (With Nuts)
Red Velvet (No Nuts)
Lemon
Porgy & Bess
Strawberry
Vanilla Cream Carmel
Turtle
Yellow Chocolate
Carrot
Plain Cheesecake
Carrot Cheesecake
Strawberry Cheesecake
Carmel Cheesecake
Turtle Cheesecake
Oreo Cheesecake
Red Velvet Cheesecake
Chocolate Turtle
Cookie Monster
Elmo
German Chocolate (Dark)
German Chocolate (Blond)
Hostess
Lemon W/Candied Lemon Rind
Oreo
PB&J
Potato Chip
Reese's Peanut Butter
Strawberry Shortcake
Sundae (Chocolate)
Sundae (Yellow Cake)
Twinkie
Vanilla Cream Carmel (VCC)
Tortue Assortment
Mint Meltaways
Raspberry Meltaways
Chocolate Dipped Potato Chips
Carmel Parfait
Strawberry Parfait
Chocolate Parfait
Banana Pudding Parfait
Milk Chocolate Vanilla
Dark Chocolate Strawberry
Mint Chocolate
Turtle Brownie
Carmel Cream Cheese Brownie
Plain Brownie
Navy Pier Menu
Nationwide Shipping Menu
Caramel Cake
. Accepting orders for shipping. Brown Sugar Bakery ships their award-winning Caramel and German Chocolate Cake on Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday of each week. To ensure freshness and timely delivery be sure to place your order the week prior to your event.
German Chocolate Cake
. Accepting orders for shipping. Brown Sugar Bakery ships their award-winning German Chocolate Cake on Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday of each week. To ensure freshness and timely delivery be sure to place your order the week prior to your event.
Tortue Assortment
Our famous Tortue Assortment is filled with jumbo fancy pecans, creamy caramel, and smothered in pure white, dark & milk chocolate. Tortues the perfect gift for any occasion. Made fresh daily. Never frozen. No preservatives. Available in a -piece or -piece custom wrapped box
Raspberry Meltaways
Raspberry melt-a-ways. A layer of creamy raspberry sandwiched between rich dark chocolate. Made fresh daily, never frozen. No preservatives.Available in -piece or -piece custom wrapped boxingredients: dark chocolate, sugar, cocoa butter, chocolate liquor, milk fat, soya lethicin (an emulsifier), vanilla, white chocolate, (sugar, hydrogenated coconut oil, non-fat milk powder, oil of peppermint, and all-natural colors.
Tortues - Milk Chocolate
Our famous Milke Chocolate Tortues are filled with jumbo fancy pecans, creamy caramel, and smothered in pure milk chocolate.Tortues the perfect gift for any occasion. Made fresh daily. Never frozen. No preservatives. Available in / custom wrapped box. Net Weight: oz / grams.Ingredients: sugar, corn syrup, evaporated milk, chocolate (sugar, chocolate liquor, cocoa butter, milk fat, soya lecithin (an emulsifier), vanilla) pecans, dairy cream & butter, salt, and natural flavors.
Mint Meltaways
Mint Melt-a-ways. A layer of smooth creamy pastel-green mint chocolate sandwiched between rich dark chocolate. Made fresh daily, never frozen. No preservatives. Available in -piece or -piece custom wrapped box.Ingredients: dark chocolate, sugar, cocoa butter, chocolate liquor, milk fat, soya lethicin (an emulsifier), vanilla, white chocolate, (sugar, hydrogenated coconut oil, non-fat milk powder, oil of raspberry, and all-natural colors.
Sea Salt Caramels
Each piece filled with rich caramel dipped in our finest dark chocolate and sprinkled with sea salt. Made fresh daily, no preservatives. Available in a -piece and -piece custom-wrapped box. Net weight: oz ( g), oz. ( g).Ingredients: sugar, corn syrup, evaporated milk, chocolate (sugar, chocolate liquor, cocoa butter, milk fat, soya lecithin (an emulsifier), vanilla) dairy cream & butter, salt, and natural flavors.
Cakes Layer - Caramel Pecan
Cakes Layer - Coconut
Cakes Layer - Dark German Chocolate
Cakes Layer - Double Dark Chocolate
Cakes Layer - Neapolitan
Cakes Layer - Obama
Cakes Layer - Pineapple Coconut
Cakes Layer - Rainbow Sherbet
Cakes Layer - Red Velvet
Cakes Layers - Caramel
Cakes Layers - Dreamsicle
Cakes Layers - Lemon
Cakes Layers - Porgy & Bess
Cakes Layers - Strawberry
Cakes Layers - Vanilla Cream & Caramel
Cakes Layer - Turtle
Cakes Layer - Yellow Chocolate
Layer Cake - Caramel
Layer Cake - Coconut
Layer Cake- Dark German Chocolate
Layer Cake- Double Dark Chocolate
Layer Cake - Dreamsicle
Layer Cake - Lemon
Layer Cake - Pineapple Coconut
Layer Cake - Porgy & Bess
Layer Cake - Rainbow Sherbet
Layer Cake - Red Velvet
Layer Cake - Strawberry
Layer Cake - Turtle
Layer Cake - Vanilla Cream & Caramel
Layer Cake - Yellow Chocolate
Pre-Order Menu
Same Day Menu (Square Test)
Layer Cake - Red Velvet
Layer Cake - Coconut
Layer Cake- Rainbow Sherbet
Layer Cake- Double Dark Chocolate
Layer Cake - Neapolitan
Premium Flavors: Turtle, Carmel Pecan, Double Dark Chocolate, Red Velvet, Pineapple Coconut, Dark German Chocolate, Coconut, Neapolitan, Rainbow Sherbet, Obama
Layer Cake- Dark German Chocolate
Layer Cake - Pineapple Coconut
Premium Flavors: Turtle, Carmel Pecan, Double Dark Chocolate, Red Velvet, Pineapple Coconut, Dark German Chocolate, Coconut, Neapolitan, Rainbow Sherbet, Obama
Layer Cake - Turtle
Cakes Layer - Rainbow Sherbet
Cakes Layer - Carmel Pecan
Cakes Layer - Red Velvet
Cakes Layer - Dark German Chocolate
Cakes Layer - Neapolitan
Cakes Layer - Pineapple Coconut
Cakes Layer - Turtle
Cakes Layer - Coconut
Cakes Layer - Obama
Cakes Layer - Double Dark Chocolate
Cake Slice - Pineapple Coconut
Cake Slice - Carmel
Pound Cake Slice - Lemon
Cake Slice - Turtle
Cake Slice - Vanilla Cream & Carmel
Cake Slice - Red Velvet
Cake Slice - Yellow Chocolate
Pound Cake Slice - Plain
Cake Slice - Carrot
Cake Slice - Taffy Apple
Cake Slice - Lemon
Cake Slice - Dark Chocolate
Cake Slice - German Chocolate
Pound Cake Slice - Carmel
Jumbo Cupcake - Red Velvet
Jumbo Cupcake - Turtle
Jumbo Cupcake - Dark Chocolate
Jumbo Cupcake - Yellow Chocolate
Jumbo Cupcake - German Chocolate
Jumbo Cupcake - Strawberry
Jumbo Cupcake - Carmel
Jumbo Cupcake - Lemon
Jumbo Cupcake - Rainbow Sherbert
Jumbo Cupcake - Vanilla Cream & Carmel
Cakes Layers - Vanilla Cream & Carmel
Cakes Layers - Strawberry
Cakes Layers - Lemon
Cakes Layers - Carmel
Cakes Layers - Porgy & Bess
Cakes Layer - Yellow Chocolate
Cakes Layers - Dreamsicle
Cheese Cake Cake Slice
Cheese Cake Slice - Carmel
Cheese Cake Slice - Turtle
Cheese Cake - Chocolate
Layer Cake - Carmel
Layers Cake - Vanilla Cream & Carmel
Layer Cake - Dreamsicl
Layer Cake - Porgy & Bess
Layer Cake - Lemon
Layers Cake - Yellow Chocolate
Layer Cake - Strawberry
Holiday Special: Layer Carmel Cake And Sweet Potato Pie
No substitutions, decoration or writing on cakes Pick up Monday Nov , Tues Nov th or Wednesday Nov th only Pick Up form th street store only We will run strict to pick up times so please confirm a time that works for you on your order. Please ensure your order has the following information or it will be considered incomplete: First and Last name Telephone Number Email Pick Up Time